“The Unmaking of a College”: Ithaca College Professors Draw Parallels Between Documentary & Their Own College

by | Apr 6, 2022 | News

On March 27, the Finger Lakes Environmental Film Festival and the Park Center for Independent Media hosted a screening and talkback of the documentary “The Unmaking of a College” at Ithaca’s local independent movie theater, Cinemapolis.

The documentary, directed by Amy Goldstein, explores the 2019 student sit-in at Hampshire College — a private, liberal arts college in Massachusetts — which lasted 75 days. The protest occurred in response to President Miriam Nelson’s attempts to give up the independence of the institution, considered one of the most experimental colleges in the United States. President Nelson planned to implement changes that would involve partnering with another college, not admitting a full 2019 freshman class, and cutting faculty and staff.

Goldstein, an alum of the college, constructed a documentation of the events through student-shot footage and interviews with alumni, staff, and students. The president eventually resigned from the college and the college remained independent.

The screening of the film was followed by a talkback with Salmaan Hameed, an associate professor of integrated science and humanities at Hampshire College. The talkback was moderated by Park Center for Independent Media Director Raza Rumi.

Hameed reflected on the events at Hampshire College, stating that he had no idea the announcement was happening and that even the academic deans did not know Nelson was going to enact this change within the college.

“Being in there was like the middle of a storm,” Hameed said. “The way the announcement was made, it was to maximize the shock. It came out of nowhere. … So I can pretty much safely say that this was one of the most stressful times in my life.”

Ithaca College Professors Patricia Rodriguez and Carlos Figueroa also joined for the discussion. They related what they witnessed in the documentary to recent conflicts between students and the administration at Ithaca College.

Rodriguez, associate professor and chair of the Department of Politics at Ithaca College, said the documentary exposed that many higher education institutions are not as transparent as they claim.

“I think that it speaks so much to the uncertainty that we’re all facing in higher ed in general, but also, in terms of small liberal arts colleges and for us [Ithaca College], it’s kind of personal, right?” Rodriguez said. “I think one of the things that we realize is how much secrecy there is behind the decision–making processes. … So that’s part of the really big frustration, as well as … the fact that as faculty members and as staff members, we really don’t have much decision–making participation at all.”

Carlos Figueroa, associate professor and legal studies coordinator in the Department of Politics at Ithaca College, commented on the difficulty of getting a college that has such stark divisions in its sub-schools, such as Ithaca College (The college is made up of five schools: the School of Business, Roy H. Park School of Communications, School of Health Sciences and Human Performance, School of Humanities and Sciences, and School of Music) to organize as a whole on one issue.

“People get divided based on their own group … as opposed to ‘Let’s focus on it’ [one common issue],” Figueroa said. “One issue that we can focus on is shared governance across the board, which is what brought people together [in the Hampshire College movement], and that is a starting point that is missing here at IC.”



More from The Edge

Damn the Court; This Is Not What Democracy Looks Like

I could wait to fully try to clear my head and calm my heart but that might not happen soon enough, and this moment “we” are in is urgent. For friends who say they have lost hope I am reminded of what I have said too often in these last few years. Hope is not an...

Tears of Joy and Hope Turn to Tears of Despair

Nearly 30 years ago, I was in the kitchen on the phone with my obstetrician.   My husband, Tim, on the other side of the house, heard me scream with joy. Life-altering news made me cry. I was going to be a mom to a daughter. And the baby, yes, at that point it was my...

Normal Does Not Exist

“We are back to normal,” proclaimed Tribeca Festival cofounder Jane Rosenthal on June 8. The Variety story featured an interview with Rosenthal and cofounding partner Robert De Niro, expounding on the joys of in-person festivals. De Niro declared “The festival is...

Media Weigh Democracy Against Ratings on Jan. 6 Hearings

On January 6, 2020, a mob of supporters to then-President Donald Trump attacked the U.S. Capitol during the certification of Joe Biden’s presidency. Violence ensued throughout the Capitol and the following months saw a continuous effort from Donald Trump and his...

Is China Going to Invade Taiwan?

Only if the U.S. tries putting missiles or a Navy base on the island. I’ve never wanted to be a war correspondent. The closest I ever came was working as a reporter for Business Week based in Hong Kong during the mid ’90s, when I was dispatched by the magazine to...

What’s in the US’s Massive Military Aid Package to Ukraine

$17 billion could buy a lot of food aid. The first point that needs to be made in addressing the colossal $40 billion Ukraine arms aid package passed by Congress and rushed by plane to Asia for President Joe Biden’s signature is that it’s not all for weapons. The...

The COVID 10 Million

Around May 15, 2022, depending on whether you doomscroll the New York Times or the Center for Disease Control, the United States reached one million COVID deaths. Nadine Burke Harris, California’s former surgeon general, declared in a May 17 Al Jazeera story that the...

NRA Convention Went on ‘As Planned’ after Uvalde Shooting

The National Rifle Association held its annual conference in Houston on Friday, just three days after and 300 miles away from the May 24 mass shooting of 19 children and two teachers at Robb Elementary School in Uvalde, Texas. Former President Donald Trump spoke at...

Breaking the ‘Shock and Familiarity’ of Mass Shootings

On May 24, a shooter in Uvalde, Texas, killed 19 children and two adults, just 10 days after a mass shooting in Buffalo, New York, that killed 10 people and injured three others. Another shooting in Tulsa, Oklahoma, killed five people including the shooter on June 1,...