On Rebuttals and Ballots for Sight and Sound’s ‘Greatest Films of All Time’ List

by | Dec 7, 2022 | Commentary, News

The Edge has leapt into the debates ignited by the December 1 publication of the Sight and Sound Greatest Films of All Time 2022 list currently crackling across social media.

We’re not just publishing rebuttals to the list. We are also publishing the nominations of different film scholars and cinephiles to the poll that proposed a more expansive view of cinema. (Full disclosure: one of the members of The Edge’s editorial team was invited to nominate but declined due to the political problems of list making and the word “greatest”). The majority of films on the list are feature-length, but there are at least two shorts.

Effusive exultations and thumbs up emojis that a woman with a daring feminist film is listed as #1 for the first time in 70 years populate these posts, many by film professors who regularly teach “Jeanne Dielmann, 23,” “Quai du Commerce 1080 Bruxelles” (1975). In the decades before streaming, you could only access the film in an art cinema or at a feminist film festival. Now you can use your credit card to pay $2.99 USD and watch it any time you want on Amazon Prime, Apple TV, or Vudu.

Distributors and film scholars underscore that Latin American films constitute a gaping absence. In our current context of a more expansive and even polemical way of programming, teaching, and writing about film influenced by postcolonialism, feminism, and critical race studies, such intensifying political critiques of the mainstream and the canon grow more pressing.

Not many scholars, distributors, journalists, or programmers seem overly excited about the rest of the films of the list, either ignoring the list entirely or determining it is status quo or old-fashioned as modes of cinema have expanded beyond features and the art cinemas of the Global North arts/industrial matrix.

The 300+ word preface on the ballot distributed to nominators advances an argument for recognizing work not on the previous 100s.

For film historian Dan Streible, this was his first invitation to vote. Since his ballot annotations were written in August 2022, they should not be read as a reaction to this week’s debates. We’ve published his list here to show that some cinephiles were thinking out of the box and beyond the art cinema canon before the current debates erupted.


More from The Edge

The 10 Freeway Has Been Reopened but L.A.’s Transit Problem Remains

During the early hours of November 11, a fire erupted in a storage yard underneath the I-10 freeway near downtown Los Angeles, structurally compromising a large section of the road and resulting in, what was at the time, claimed to be an indefinite closure of the...

From My Body to Yours, and Gaza to the World

A Meditation on Death, Killing, and Possibility I knew my body was healing from the surgery when I found myself ready to engage with the world and posted on Facebook: I am always anti-zionist. And never an antisemite. And always an anti-racist feminist against...

On the Tragic Inevitability of Stacking Corpses

War. Genocide. Pandemics. Heat. Famine. Racism. Misogyny. Hunger. Violence. There are so many ways for mortal beings to die, especially the most vulnerable, and too often these deaths are state sponsored, sped by capitalism, and/or preventable. We — humans and...

“Barbie”: An Anti-Racist Socialist Feminist Meditation

I started writing this the day “Barbie” was opening in the theatres. I had not seen it yet, because I am writing less about the film and more about the cultural and political moment we inhabit as it opens. I went as soon as I finished an early draft, exactly one week...

Supreme Court Ruling in Stalking Case Hurts Victims

Stalking is a social and public health emergency. Unfortunately, the Supreme Court’s ruling in Counterman v. Colorado makes things easier for abusers and harder for victims. A form of gender-based violence, stalking affects more than 13 million people annually in the...

The Rogue Court’s Reactionary Radicalism

This Is a Catastrophe. I am finishing the writing of this piece shortly after the July 4 holiday. This is significant — to wonder who this country is now, and before. I began writing it while riding the bus into NYC from Ithaca, NY, on Friday, June 30, while the last...

Held vs. Montana: The Future of the Climate Crisis Fight

As the courtroom seats began filling in the first judicial court in Helena, the capital city of Montana, local community members and officials prepared to hear the long-awaited testimonies from plaintiffs who allege state officials have violated their constitutional...