Overturning Roe v. Wade is Immoral and Dangerous

by | Jul 21, 2022 | Commentary

I no longer have a uterus. But I do have two daughters, 18 and 20. And I am horrified and enraged by the loss of the constitutional right to abortion. In 2022, according to a Supreme Court majority, states cannot regulate gun ownership, but they can — and should — regulate uteruses and the people in whose bodies they reside.

I am also an award-winning women’s health scholar. I can tell you that the majority ruling in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization is based on scientific inaccuracies about fetal development. It also runs counter to widespread public opinion in the United States regarding access to abortion.

The decision is already causing unequal and devastating harm based on race, class, citizenship status, language, age, and geography. Middle-class white women, like me, have long been able to secure abortions, and they will continue to do so. Many others will suffer unnecessarily — and even die — attempting to access health care.

Dobbs is both political and partisan. SCOTUS can no longer — if ever it was able to — claim objective authority about any matter, which bodes ill for the future of our democracy. This is Trump’s legacy, to be sure — but the seeds were planted long ago, during the Reagan Administration if not during slavery.

Reagan’s sun-drenched campaign tagline, “Morning in America,” was never meant for those on the margins, or even those at the moderate center. Overturning Roe has long been a fundamentalist conservative end game. Unfortunately, despite specious appeals to fetal well-being, the Supreme Court’s decision will not save lives.

Indeed, states seeking to limit or ban abortion are those with the highest infant mortality rates in the country: Mississippi, Arkansas, Oklahoma, South Dakota, Alabama, Tennessee, Indiana, Georgia, Ohio, Louisiana, and North Carolina. Hotbeds of anti-abortion policies, they contribute disproportionately to our nation’s appalling overall infant death rates.

Globally, the U.S. ranks 53rd in infant mortality — well below all other industrialized nations and many developing nations. This is criminal, as the vast majority of these deaths are preventable.

The U.S. also has a tragically high maternal mortality rate, especially in states with abortion barriers or bans. Lack of access to safe and legal abortion is a leading cause of maternal deaths, and abortion has time and again been proven far safer than pregnancy. Black women are most at risk in this country, dying at three to four times the rate of white women from pregnancy-related causes.

And yet, while mothers and babies perish, leaving grieving loved ones behind, those in power look the other way. Or worse, enact policies cloaked in the language of “life” that in fact lead only to premature death. Overturning Roe in the throes of a devastating maternal and infant health crisis is the very antithesis of “pro-life.”

It is immoral and profoundly racist.


Monica J. Casper, a sociologist and bioethicist, is Professor Emeritus of Gender and Women’s Studies at the University of Arizona. She is the author of “Babylost: Racism, Survival, and the Quiet Politics of Infant Mortality, from A to Z”, published by Rutgers University Press in 2022.

Image by Sarah Penney on Unsplash.


More from The Edge

On the Tragic Inevitability of Stacking Corpses

War. Genocide. Pandemics. Heat. Famine. Racism. Misogyny. Hunger. Violence. There are so many ways for mortal beings to die, especially the most vulnerable, and too often these deaths are state sponsored, sped by capitalism, and/or preventable. We — humans and...

“Barbie”: An Anti-Racist Socialist Feminist Meditation

I started writing this the day “Barbie” was opening in the theatres. I had not seen it yet, because I am writing less about the film and more about the cultural and political moment we inhabit as it opens. I went as soon as I finished an early draft, exactly one week...

Supreme Court Ruling in Stalking Case Hurts Victims

Stalking is a social and public health emergency. Unfortunately, the Supreme Court’s ruling in Counterman v. Colorado makes things easier for abusers and harder for victims. A form of gender-based violence, stalking affects more than 13 million people annually in the...

The Rogue Court’s Reactionary Radicalism

This Is a Catastrophe. I am finishing the writing of this piece shortly after the July 4 holiday. This is significant — to wonder who this country is now, and before. I began writing it while riding the bus into NYC from Ithaca, NY, on Friday, June 30, while the last...

Held vs. Montana: The Future of the Climate Crisis Fight

As the courtroom seats began filling in the first judicial court in Helena, the capital city of Montana, local community members and officials prepared to hear the long-awaited testimonies from plaintiffs who allege state officials have violated their constitutional...

The Radical Restorative Justice of The People’s CDC

The Pandemic is Not Over Four days before the 2022 State of the Union address, the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (the CDC) made a change to the risk-prevention pandemic map of the United States that changed the color of the map from red to green....