‘I Still Dream About Being in the Newsroom Three Nights a Week’: Journalists Discuss the Decline in Local News at Suffolk University

by | Sep 30, 2022 | News

On September 29, a panel of seasoned journalists and scholars gathered at Suffolk University Law School to participate in a discussion on the crisis in community journalism and local governance in the United States. The panel, titled “The Decline Local News and Rise of Polarization,” was to examine the  effect this decline has had on government accountability and democracy more generally.

Moderator Dan Kennedy of Northeastern school of Journalism opened by acknowledging the pessimistic tone of the event’s title. “The title of this program is pretty depressing,” Kennedy recognized. “There are, in fact, plenty of reasons to be pessimistic. According to researcher Penny Abernathy of Northwestern University, some 2,500 newspapers — about a quarter of the total across the country — have shut down since 2005. More than a fifth of Americans live in ‘news deserts’ and lack the reliable journalism they need to govern themselves in a democracy.”

Joshua Darr, an associate professor of political communication at Louisiana State University, examined issues around the concept of polarization. He mentioned a study in which a local newspaper in California dropped national politics from their opinion page for an entire month. “We found that [the newspaper’s] mentions of [political] parties went down… and people were reading much more about California issues and far less about the national party issues that were happening 3,000 miles away in Washington, D.C.”

Darr argued, “What happens when you read national news is you read about partisan conflict and that reinforces divisions, it reinforces partisan identity… Polarization slows when newspapers become more local. The problem is, it’s so easy to get national news. It’s a lot harder to get local news.”

Renée Loth, an opinion columnist and former editorial-page editor for The Boston Globe, took on a more optimistic tone, bringing up many examples of successes in local journalism.

“In West Virginia, the Mountain State Spotlight teamed up with ProPublica to write a searing investigative series on the foster care system in that state. What was striking to me in that project was that all of the reporters were under 35, so there is a future.”

Charles St. Amand, a practitioner in residence in Suffolk’s communication and journalism department, grew emotional when he offered a more personal perspective on local journalism. The 31-year veteran of community journalism recalled his time as editor of the Sentinel & Enterprise in Fitchburg before it was gutted by corporate consolidation.

“I still dream about being in the newsroom three nights a week,” St. Amand said as he choked back tears. “This decline of local news is not the newsrooms’ fault. This is every newsroom. The folks at The Globe can tell you, they’re leaner [in staff] than they were.”

The panelists discussed how achievements in local news in areas populated primarily by rich, white Democrats are generally positive, but not as helpful as they could be for the wider American populace. “These great successes are not in the places that need them most,” said Loth.

Dan Kennedy stressed the need for ingenuity when it comes to strengthening and reimagining local journalism in the years ahead:

“At the very least, we are living at time where some new thinking is needed. We are also living at a time when many Americans are highly engaged with national news and especially with the divisive talk shows that are carried on cable news outlets. At a time like this, local journalism could be a way to bring us together. Community journalism at its best can way to bring people of different viewpoints together so they can work on common goal. They challenge is to find ways of providing such journalism at a time when technological, economic, and social forces make that more difficult than ever.”

 

More from The Edge

The New Long COVID is College Without Classes

I was punched in the gut. It hurt. I thought this would be the seminar session to bring all the theories and histories of documentary across analog and digital together with a big political and epistemological impact. But I should have summoned my semiotic training to...

Warhol, Art, and Capitalism Before the Supreme Court

The Andy Warhol Foundation has lost its suit against photographer Lynn Goldsmith. The Supreme Court’s May 18, 2023, ruling positioned the decision as a defense of lesser known artists against famous ones. The majority argued that Fair Use was not applicable when...

How Media Bias Twists Public Perception of the Writers’ Strike

Outside of the corporate offices and backlots of Netflix, Disney, NBC, Universal, and Warner Brothers, masses of protestors stand with signs that range from serious to hilarious, all with the same message: writers need to be fairly paid for their work. Corporate media...

Motherhood, Technology, and Natalia Almada’s “Users”

Natalia Almada’s documentary essay film “Users” (2021) questions a mother’s deep ambivalence about technology. But the film’s aesthetics makes clear that she has already chosen technology. The film is the binational Mexican American director’s first shot in the United...

Guilty of Sexual Abuse (But Not Rape?)

On Contemptuous Men and the Women who Fight Back A short note about the subtitle before I begin: it is interesting how these gender terms hold sometimes in all their simplicity and binary force. Other than the title, when I use the term woman/en it is inclusive of...

The Drifting Smoke of the Burned-Over District

South Butler, New York, is a forgotten byway in American history. Its moment of notoriety came and went. Now it is just a crossroad hamlet struggling to matter like so many other such places in rural America. But once it did matter. In the decades before the Civil...

Capturing the Latino Vote

The 2024 election season has begun. Candidates identify political and policy priorities. Voters constantly wonder where on the political spectrum the country will land. At the same time, a political messaging battle about voter turnout and possible voter suppression...