Colonialism and Racism are ‘Etched into Global Conservation’ — Prakash Kashwan

by | Oct 27, 2021 | Commentary, Videos

On Tuesday, October 26, Dr. Prakash Kashwan joined Ithaca College professor Dr. Jake Brenner for a discussion on environmental justice, interdisciplinary scholarship, and the legacy of colonialism in conservation. Dr. Kashwan is an environmental justice scholar-activist and a professor of political science at the University of Connecticut, Storrs.

PCIM Director Raza Rumi introduced the evening’s conversation, citing alarming figures from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change’s (IPCC) August report. Rumi’s summary illustrated humanity’s immense warming of the planet and highlighted media’s tendency to obscure how the climate emergency exacerbates natural disasters and causes adverse impacts on immigration, health, world economy, and global patterns of equality.

Dr. Kashwan explained the various fields he teaches and engages with in scholarship, including human rights, environmental justice, south Asia in world politics, climate justice, and forest and water conservation. Dr. Brenner asked him to elaborate on his scholarship method of “workshopping,” which can pertain to research in any of these fields. Just as carpenters make pieces of furniture to fit the relevant context and use an array tools to craft them, “good scholarship should be like workshop: address the particular context in which a question is being asked, then … combine different methodological and theoretical frameworks to address problems.”

Furthering the issue of interdisciplinary research, Dr. Brenner wondered, “How can we forge science collaborations to promote social justice outcomes?” Dr. Kashwan named a hypothetical research project combining ecology and social science to emphasize that “the best interdisciplinary scholarship happens when people trained in complimentary disciplines work together.” In this instance, environmental science students and researchers should always consider how the problem at hand relates to our real-world challenges.

Considering real-world impacts remained a point of emphasis during their talk. Dr. Brenner cited a quote from Dr. Kashwan’s article in Environment magazine asserting that “the effects of colonialism and racism are etched into the dominant philosophy, models, and institutional apparatus of global conservation.” In terms of “literal history,” Kashwan explained that “today’s global conservation emerged during colonial times, when the prevailing wisdom and ‘consensus’ was that poor people in Africa and Asia were too ignorant and illiterate to care about the environment. So, white men, colonial administrators and scientists, needed to conserve wildlife, biodiversity, and other natural resources to protect them from hungry and ignorant people.”

Dr. Kashwan further detailed that “The entire institutional structure, the systems for promoting global conservation, were meant to exclude local people from national parks and wildlife sanctuaries. We call this the fines, fences, and firearms approach,” since fences were built to keep locals off designated land, with severe fees and sometimes shoot-to-kill orders punishing those who crossed them. “This is not a metaphorical reference; there have been actual shootings in Africa and Asia.” In India, 25 people were killed in 5 years to protect rhinos. But rhino hunters carry rifles, “so you can’t shoot the real poachers — you can only shoot poor people.”

The conversation interrogated the production of knowledge, particularly pertaining to the relationship between researchers and local people. Dr. Brenner described how imbalanced power dynamics perpetuates inequality and injustice, and Dr. Kashwan delved into the issue of expertise and appropriation. The history of environmental science is populated by white men who hired locals, usually with an understanding of regional ecology, as laborers, only to name species after themselves without acknowledging or compensating local communities. As part of undoing this legacy, Kashwan stated that researchers should explicitly acknowledge local people, and ensure they gain the benefits of studies.

To close the evening’s discussion, Dr. Kashwan encouraged doing away with the false binary between nature and society — reintegrating these concepts into one should shift our perspectives and consumption habits to decolonize notions of land ownership and allow biodiversity to flourish everywhere. The maintenance of manicured lawns, for instance, smothers natural conservation and generates considerable fossil fuel emissions.


More from The Edge

From Enforced Hijabs to Enforced Pregnancies

Seeing and Looking and Thinking Anew We — the inclusive we — need to see this newest devastating crisis of democracy in the U.S. with renewed urgency because it has too long a history. Look at what is happening to Iranian women (and Saudi, and Indian, and Afghan) and...

November Elections Spur Urgent Calls for Pro-Democracy Coverage

As the 2022 midterm elections approach in November, mainstream media have been covering the leadup to the vote with usual commitment to framing Republicans and Democrats equally, even as a subset of Republicans attack the integrity of elections to gain power. This...

The Continuing Trouble and Tragedy within ‘Death of a Salesman’

It is clear that the way people react to Arthur Miller’s 1949 play “Death of a Salesman” is as unpredictable as the play itself. Sympathies are pulled in every direction. With the play currently revived for the sixth time on Broadway, let us take a moment to think...

You Cannot Silence Us: Exiled Writers Speak At Ithaca College

On September 22, the Park Center for Independent Media hosted a discussion with dissident writers who were forced from their homelands and found sanctuary through a City of Asylum in Ithaca, Pittsburgh, or Detroit. The event, which was attended by nearly 70 Ithaca...

Upending Arthur Miller: A Clarion Call to Our Cultural Emergency

There’s so much I could say about Claire Gleitman the woman, the colleague, the director, and the Dean, as she has been invaluable to my career and my happiness in this job. Her friendship has been an unwavering goodness in my life. But tonight, it is Claire’s...

Queen Elizabeth’s Funeral: When Bravery Gets Old

Social media has been rife with criticism of Queen Elizabeth’s funeral, even from those members of the public who loved her. It represents money wasted in a nation facing financial crisis, the denial of British colonialism and slavery that the royal family has never...

Southwest ‘Megadrought’: Heat and Dryness Worst in 1,200 Years

In 1988, NASA climatologist James Hansen testified before Congress about a warming planet during a summer of unprecedented heatwaves and drought in 40 states. His historic wakeup call failed to galvanize economic systems and government to take preventive action. Now,...

PCIM Publishes Archives from the Los Angeles Vanguard

View the full Vanguard Archive here. “The Vanguard is more than a newspaper, it is an organizing tool for community groups and individuals to fight back through citizen action. FIGHT BACK will be a regular feature of such efforts.” The mission statement published in...