‘The Facebook Papers’ Confirm Commitment to ‘Profit Over Safety’

by | Nov 10, 2021 | News

Whistleblower and former Facebook product manager Frances Haugen released thousands of pages of Facebook’s internal documents, known as “The Facebook Papers,” to various media outlets in October, revealing and confirming many troubling details about the company and CEO  Mark Zuckerberg.

Politico reported on employee complaints that “Facebook routinely makes exceptions for powerful actors when enforcing content policy.” The company has a lobbying and government relations shop led by former Republican operative Joel Kaplan that weighs in on free speech issues, largely to protect prominent right-wing figures. The company’s employees argued that Facebook was breaking its own policies to “keep political figures happy, even overriding concerns about public safety.”

Kaplan’s team has protected pro-Trump accounts, such as Charlie Kirk and conservative publication Breitbart, from consequences for violating Facebook’s misinformation policies — Zuckerberg has even gotten personally involved. These accounts verify journalism from past years showing how the platform privileges right-wing voices.

According to the Washington Post, the documents show Zuckerberg’s public statements often contradict Facebook’s research; he told Congress the company removes 94 percent of the hate speech it finds, but inside Facebook, “researchers estimated that the company was removing less than 5 percent of all hate speech.” And while Zuckerberg testified in March 2021 that evidence fails to show social networks polarize people, an employee wrote in 2020 that “[w]e’ve known for over a year now that our recommendation systems can very quickly lead users down the path to conspiracy theories and groups.”

The leaked documents additionally revealed that the company is aware Facebook is used to enable “domestic servitude,” a form of human trafficking; Zuckerberg vetoed plans to include a Spanish version of a voting information program to avoid the appearance of favoring Democrats; and the CEO’s actions show that, despite his public comments lauding free speech, he was willing to censor “anti-government dissidents” in Vietnam to protect Facebook’s market in the country.

Facebook’s internal research scrutinized its like and share buttons, groups feature, and other tools that dictate how its 3.5 billion users interact online. Results from studies were often negative, showing that people misused key features, or that those featured amplified toxic content.

As the New York Times wrote,

“In an August 2019 internal memo, several researchers said it was Facebook’s ‘core product mechanics’ — meaning the basics of how the product functioned — that had let misinformation and hate speech flourish on the site.

‘The mechanics of our platform are not neutral,’ they concluded.”

The practices these documents revealed sparked public backlash, during which Facebook initiated a rebrand and renamed itself Meta. The company’s stock fell about 5 percent in recent weeks, but it remains to be seen if the Securities and Exchange Commission — the federal agency where Frances Haugen sent the documents — will impose fines and restrictions on leaders for misleading investors, as whistleblowers have claimed in at least nine complaints.

The company should be held accountable for careless oversight of how its billions of users interact with and share information on its service. There must be an answer when “Facebook, over and over again, has shown it chooses profit over safety.”

 

Image by AP Photo / Thibault Camus

More from The Edge

From Enforced Hijabs to Enforced Pregnancies

Seeing and Looking and Thinking Anew We — the inclusive we — need to see this newest devastating crisis of democracy in the U.S. with renewed urgency because it has too long a history. Look at what is happening to Iranian women (and Saudi, and Indian, and Afghan) and...

November Elections Spur Urgent Calls for Pro-Democracy Coverage

As the 2022 midterm elections approach in November, mainstream media have been covering the leadup to the vote with usual commitment to framing Republicans and Democrats equally, even as a subset of Republicans attack the integrity of elections to gain power. This...

The Continuing Trouble and Tragedy within ‘Death of a Salesman’

It is clear that the way people react to Arthur Miller’s 1949 play “Death of a Salesman” is as unpredictable as the play itself. Sympathies are pulled in every direction. With the play currently revived for the sixth time on Broadway, let us take a moment to think...

You Cannot Silence Us: Exiled Writers Speak At Ithaca College

On September 22, the Park Center for Independent Media hosted a discussion with dissident writers who were forced from their homelands and found sanctuary through a City of Asylum in Ithaca, Pittsburgh, or Detroit. The event, which was attended by nearly 70 Ithaca...

Upending Arthur Miller: A Clarion Call to Our Cultural Emergency

There’s so much I could say about Claire Gleitman the woman, the colleague, the director, and the Dean, as she has been invaluable to my career and my happiness in this job. Her friendship has been an unwavering goodness in my life. But tonight, it is Claire’s...

Queen Elizabeth’s Funeral: When Bravery Gets Old

Social media has been rife with criticism of Queen Elizabeth’s funeral, even from those members of the public who loved her. It represents money wasted in a nation facing financial crisis, the denial of British colonialism and slavery that the royal family has never...

Southwest ‘Megadrought’: Heat and Dryness Worst in 1,200 Years

In 1988, NASA climatologist James Hansen testified before Congress about a warming planet during a summer of unprecedented heatwaves and drought in 40 states. His historic wakeup call failed to galvanize economic systems and government to take preventive action. Now,...

PCIM Publishes Archives from the Los Angeles Vanguard

View the full Vanguard Archive here. “The Vanguard is more than a newspaper, it is an organizing tool for community groups and individuals to fight back through citizen action. FIGHT BACK will be a regular feature of such efforts.” The mission statement published in...