Indy Journalists: ‘We Are Not The New York Times — We Take Sides’

by | Aug 6, 2020 | Commentary

Four esteemed voices in media joined PCIM on July 29 to discuss recent changes in journalism amid pandemic and protest. Moderated by PCIM Director Raza Rumi, the conversation invited valuable perspectives from each of the four panelists: The Independent’s chief U.S. correspondent Andrew Buncombe, Montclair State University assistant professor Dr. Tara L. Conley, The Nation editor D.D. Guttenplan, and newsroom editorial director Amanda Silverman of Mother Jones.

Watch the full webinar recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=roXrZ23i21U

Guttenplan began the conversation with insights that echoed throughout the evening, including the coronavirus pandemic’s impact on The Nation’s operations. Given the rampant science denialism surrounding COVID-19 and global warming, he illustrated how science journalism has been diminished just as its importance has increased. He also explored journalists’ responsibility to protect individuals’ identities at protests against racial injustice.

Buncombe described how he was arrested in Seattle while covering a Black Lives Matter protest. He published a full account at The Independent, but further detailed in this webinar the immense privileges of being a white man with a press badge. He spoke too of journalists’ great responsibilities and of interviewing standoffish supporters at Trump rallies.

Contextualizing protests as a media scholar, Dr. Tara L. Conley affirmed the value of independent reporting, which often offers more comprehensive framing than mainstream news when covering communities of color. Conley noted that the moment of reckoning gripping the U.S. can lead to positive change if we preserve institutions that allow for self expression.

Amanda Silverman described the rapid pace the pandemic and nationwide protests demanded of the Mother Jones newsroom. At the small nonprofit outlet, it’s understood that every story can’t get equal coverage, so the past months have required diligent communication and delegation to decide on and publish the most meaningful pieces.

Watch the full webinar recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=roXrZ23i21U

More from The Edge

Fake News or State News? Trump’s First 100 Days Blur the Line

“Over the past months, it has become clear that I would not be allowed to run the show as I have always run it, to make independent decisions based on what was right for ‘60 Minutes,’ right for the audience,” exclaimed top executive producer of the CBS News show 60...

Winners to Attend the 17th Annual Izzy Award Celebration at Ithaca College

The Park Center for Independent Media (PCIM) at Ithaca College is honored to announce that this year’s Izzy Award “for outstanding achievement in independent media” will be shared by three journalists and two outlets that undertook path-breaking and in-depth reporting...

The Use of Deadly Sarin Nerve Gas During the Secret War on Laos

Operation Tailwind Revisited after CIA Report to Kissinger Released Picture this scenario: It is September 11, 1970. American commandoes wearing nondescript fatigues devoid of insignia and dog tags and carrying weapons not made in the USA attack a North Vietnamese...

Awaiting Fascism on Inauguration Day

In its Misogynist, Racist, Newest Forms As we wait for Trump and his tech-bros to take over, the waiting unsettles and disorients. So, this is my offering for inauguration day. Do not passively submit. Do not feel helpless. Feel courageous rather than scared. Find a...

Senators Must Resist Trump’s Cabinet of Sexual Abusers

Trump’s cabinet and advisor choices are shaping up to be a who’s who of alleged sexual abusers and harassers. Pete Hegseth, Trump’s pick for defense secretary, has been accused of raping a woman in 2007. Education department pick Linda McMahon was named in a lawsuit...

Nominations Now Open for Annual “Izzy Award” for Independent Media

The Izzy Award will celebrate its 17th year this coming spring, and nominations are officially open for work produced during the 2024 calendar year. The Park Center for Independent Media at Ithaca College (PCIM) will again grant this honor — named after legendary...